June Rey Peñafiel – How NOT To Empower Youth In Agriculture

Journalists, please be careful with your hype! 
(“Hyperbole” image[1] from Li’l But Mighty)

Especially about individual successful farmers. Now then, the digital newspaper story “Young Maguindanao Farmer Empowers Youth Via Agriculture[2]” by ANN (Author Not Named, 19 August 2021, Philippine Canadian Inquirer), has 3 lessons: (1) Journalism, (2) Empowerment, and (3) Agriculture. I’m not exaggerating!

1st Lesson: Journalism

ANN says June Rey Peñafiel, above, a 27-year-old farmer in Maguindanao, has harvested 12 metric tons (MT)/hectare with hybrid rice SL-8H, planting seeds from the Department of Agriculture (DA) under the Hybridization Program. June Rey has been planting rice since 2013, twice a year. He has enjoyed per hectare a return on investment (ROI) of 4 times, gross income being P160,000 and gross expenses P40,000.

Yes, hybrid rice enriches him with that fantastic ROI! But that is a singular story. According to DA Hybrid Rice Program Adviser Frisco Malabanan, there are still areas that have not attained even the potential yield of 6 to 7 MT/ha[3]. Dreams that have not come true.

Consider ANN’s claim in her title: “Young Maguindanao Farmer Empowers Youth Via Agriculture” – ANN is claiming that with his continuing hybrid rice success, thereby June Rey’s triumph has demonstrated this:

All Filipino youth can be successful in agriculture by simply following June Rey and planting SL-8H hybrid rice! This is Hyperbole, and in journalism it is common to exaggerate the news. No Sir, no Ma’am! “One swallow does not make a summer” – Aristotle.

2nd Lesson: Empowerment

With his SL-8H success story, June Rey is not thereby empowering the youth – the technology & system of cultivation of hybrid rice is already there and has not been supplied or discovered by this young farmer. Not only that – empowerment includes the ability to obtain adequate funding, proceed to production, processing, storage and marketing. And yes, the seeds he planted came from the DA – that is not personal empowerment. Claiming “sipag at tiyaga” (industry & persistence) as his own contribution to his phenomenal success is inadequate, even simplistic.

3rd Lesson: Agriculture

No matter how rewarding, the growing of hybrid rice is not all there is to agriculture! What about multiple cropping? The choice(s) of crop(s) depend(s) on soil(s) & climate(s) in the region(s), target market(s), and competition(s).

ANN also mentions that June Rey is looking into other income opportunities via diversified farming, not only rice farming. “Diversified farming requires farm practices that will give a high ROI and, especially, needs a skillful farmer like (June Rey).” And so June Rey has in his farm a fishpond and water reservoir for irrigating his crops almost all year-round.

ANN says, “(June Rey) never doubts his capability and knowledge when it comes to farming and (some fruits) of his labor (are) in acquiring his own harvester and tractor.”

The June Rey Peñafiel narrative is very encouraging, but applauding to high heavens a single success story is ignoring the paradigms of association, cooperation and partnership in agriculture that, following Secretary of Agriculture William Dar’s national vision, we must pursue primarily.@517


[1]https://www.lilbutmightyenglish.com/blog/hyperbole-exaggerating-to-make-a-point

[2]https://canadianinquirer.net/2021/08/young-maguindanao-farmer-empowers-youth-via-agriculture/

[3]https://www.bworldonline.com/hybrid-rice-areas-seen-yielding-up-to-12-tons-per-hectare/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Knorr Of Big Business Unilever Thinks Big Business Regenerative Agriculture – My Tiny Country PH Also Should!

Image
“Knorr’s plan for 50 regenerative agriculture projects is predicted to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and water use by an estimated 30% while improving biodiversity, soil health and livelihoods.” That is regenerative agriculture (RA) news by Julian Cirineo (05 Nov 2021, “Unilever Wants To Rethink How Farms Work To Secure Food And Resources For The Future,” Rappler , rappler.com ). Note: 50 (not 5 only) RA projects to improve greenhouse gas emissions (GHGs) and water use by 30% – plus improving biodiversity, soil health and livelihoods. Note the last 7 words in the above paragraph. How can RA improve biodiversity? RA requires that the farmer practices multiculture (a few or many crops grown at the same time in the same place), where monoculture (such as rice-only or corn-only) is the practice – the biodiversity improves crop health because of the ensuing balance of nature, such as some organisms feed on other organisms that would otherwise become pests or cause diseases. RA is your
Read more

In Looking At The Crown Of Thorns, I Found The Clowns

Image
We could use a surprise sense of humor!  Yes, especially on the wide problematic fields of Agriculture. There was this news that some high PH government officials wanted to probe Vice President Leni Robredo for “competing against” PH agencies in providing much-needed assistances during this coronavirus lockdown, and Marigs Laririt shared a picture-story on Facebook quoting Ms Leni as saying, “I didn’t know it was competition. I didn’t see any competitors!” Ms Marigs says, “Ay, parang friends ko kung sumagot si Mam.” (Ay, with Mam, it’s just like my friends answering back.) That is a two-handed backslap, and you can imagine the lady laughing! She is the humor-monger; they are the clowns. Today is Friday, 03 April 2020 and in one account ( Wikipedia ), Friday the 3 rd of April was crucifixion of Jesus and his crowning of thorns [1] . (images: Crown of Thorns [2]  from St Anthony Messenger , 1 st clown [3]  from The Guardian , 2 nd clown [4]  from Shutterstock ) About the living clowns I
Read more

“Natural Farming” – Aggie Journalists, We Must Be Careful With The Terms We Use!

Image
Look at the contrasting images: Which one is correct in claiming what is being practiced is “natural farming”? Top Image: This one accompanies the Anonymous WWF-Philippines story, “Mindanao Farmers Start Off the Year with Natural Farming Systems Technology” published online December 2019 [1] . The World Wide Fund, WWF, is a very credible international source of knowledge on conservation, right? Not this time. Very clearly, you can see the white plastic mulch covering the furrows and bare soil in-between them. Mr or Ms Anonymous, the plastic mulch is not natural. The soil not covered in-between furrows is not natural. So much soil bare, not natural, allowing so much natural water wasted because it had evaporated from the unprotected, hot soil surface! That is not conservation; that is not natural. The term “natural” is used here very carelessly . Aggie journalists, wake up! How come I noticed all that immediately when I saw the photograph? Because I learned my organic farming more t
Read more